January
19th 2007.
One gripe that always comes to the fore whenever
we do a brake job, is the fact that the brake
discs are non machinable
and have to be replaced.
People always find it incredible that discs
that were new only eighteen months ago are now beyond
repair.
The problem, as always, is rust build up in
the centre of the disc that stops the cooling fins
from pumping air, causing the
discs to overheat and therefore, to distort.
Machining such discs does very little good,
since this does not remove the rust in the centre
of the disc and now the steel
is thinner and without any cooling, even more
susceptible to warpage, which causes severe
brake pedal vibrations.
It's quite likely that in a dry, always warm,
atmosphere as we find in Arizona, discs will last
longer, but from Fargo to Chicago
to Montreal, wherever ice melting rock salt
is used, brake systems take a real beating from
corrosion.
Fortunately, the cost of high quality discs
has been cut in half over the last ten years and
now the cost of a new disc, on the average
new car, is not much more than the cost of technician
time on a lathe to machine the old ones.
I've always wondered if other, non rusting materials,
could not be found, although I know that stainless
steel is not an option, due to
its' galling tendency. It is a very difficult
material to machine properly and it's obvious
that its metallurgical characteristics disqualify
it for use as a friction surface.
Now, finally, the high tech ceramic discs have
started to become noticed and although I may never
see it happen, the non rusting,
"lifetime warranted" disc may be on the horizon.
Carbon-ceramic brakes have built a glamorous
reputation in Formula One racing, creating vivid
images of discs glowing red
during hard braking at the end of long straightaways.
Their high cost limited them to exotic performance
cars. But carbon-ceramic brakes are now available
on cars priced
as low as 60,000 euros (about US$80,000 at
current exchange rates). And a new manufacturing
process could make them
affordable for even budget-minded enthusiasts.
The technology has been slow to spread to production
vehicles since it was introduced in racing
15 years ago.
Porsche first offered a carbon-ceramic brake
option on the 911 GT2 in the late 1990s, followed
by the more
mainstream 911 Turbo in 2000.
Today, carbon-ceramic brakes are optional on
all Ferraris, most Lamborghinis and Porsches
and the Bentley Continental GT
These cars are priced above US$133,000.
The percentage of buyers choosing this option
ranges from more than half for Ferrari models
to 6 percent for the Audi RS 4.
For enthusiasts, the performance-driving benefits
-- less weight, better handling because of reduced
unsprung weight
(the mass of the body and components not supported
by the suspension), durability and fade resistance
-- make the high
price worthwhile.
But if the price falls dramatically, carbon-ceramic
brakes also could appeal to more thrifty
buyers.
Carbon-ceramic brake discs last four times
longer than conventional steel discs, so owners
are unlikely to replace
carbon-ceramic discs. Brake pads last longer
on the carbon-ceramic systems, too. But at $50 to
$60 a disc for steel
discs and $665 to $2,660 a disc for carbon-ceramic,
owners cannot recoup their cost on the more
durable system.
The big step
SGL Carbon AG, of Wiesbaden, Germany, and Audi
AG are trying to reduce manufacturing costs for
carbon discs
by moving from batch production to a continuous
process.
Since last year, Audi and SGL have been working
to establish automated production and the cost
of a disc will come
down to 350 euros (about $465) with the new
process.
Audi declined to comment on the technology.
Antonio Ferreira, manager of European component
forecasts at CSM Worldwide in London, is skeptical
of carbons
broader market potential, even with reduced
costs.
"You would need huge volumes to get the price
down," he says. "Suppliers would have to come
to a two-digit price (per disc).
Nothing else is feasible when a complete braking
system is not even into three figures."
At Italy's Brembo, which has a 60 percent
market share in top-end sports- and luxury-car
brakes, carbon-ceramic is still
in a "quasi-prototype" phase.
Light and durable
But Vavassori is optimistic, saying the technology's
lower weight and long life could become
as important as its
extreme performance.
"We haven't seen the full potential for carbon
brakes yet, they can save 40 kilograms (88 pounds)
on an extreme car
where mass is important. And in the future,
we may see wider adoption in other segments, too."
The key to lowering costs is simplifying production.
"It's not mechanical but chemical," said Brembo's
Vavassori. "We start from powders and end up with
a lightweight disc,
but an expensive one."
Versions of the carbon brakes for cars must
be even more sophisticated than those on airplanes
or race cars.
The process is similar to how nature creates
coal and extremely hard substances like diamonds,
some processes are
lengthy, demanding three weeks in the chamber
to go through a thermal cycle.
How it works
Carbon-ceramic brakes use the same principle
as ordinary disc brakes. Stationary twin calipers
clamp onto both sides
of a disc rotating next to each wheel of a car,
slowing it by friction.
The energy of the car's momentum is transformed
into heat at the point of the friction, so brakes
can get extremely hot.
Carbon-ceramic brakes use carbon fiber and
ceramic materials that are stable at temperatures
that would make steel
discs bendable. Performance doesn't diminish,
leading to fade, with repeated use.
Carbon-ceramic brakes also typically use larger
calipers to spread the clamping force over a wider
area, improving
braking performance.
Race-car brakes must be warmed before they work
properly. For passenger cars, carbon-ceramic
brakes must be fully
effective immediately. The discs and brake
pads are more sophisticated, with carbon fibers
arranged to strengthen the
disc and conduct heat away from the surface.
Bentley: A demanding case:
Weighing 5,258 pounds and capable of 198 mph,
the front-engine Bentley Continental GT has
almost certainly the most
demanding braking task of any production car.
Midengine cars such as the Bugatti Veyron have
it easier. Their weight distribution means that
all four wheels can share
more of the braking effort. On the Continental,
the front brakes do most of the work.
The Continental GT already had the biggest
brake discs in the industry at 16.2 inches.
and now they've broken their own
record, with a 420-millimeter (16.8-inch)
carbon-ceramic disc, which is half the weight and
gives lower unsprung and
rotating masses.
The ceramic brakes also have superior fade
resistance and improve steering precision.
Pad life has tripled, and discs
should last the life of the car.