Jim Kenzie
Toronto Star
About the only people who might not be happy about the 2008 Volkswagen
City Golf and
City Jetta would be those who bought the 2007 models.
Because the new ones offer significant upgrades at insignificant price
increases.
The 2008 City Golf starts at $15,300, up $400 from last year, while the City
Jetta starts at $16,900, a $200 hike.
Both City Golf (due in November) and City Jetta (already arrived) get revised
exteriors – just about every body panel
but the roof and door skins is new or revised.
VW people will tell you the cars look "totally different'' from last year.
Well, a mother can tell her twins apart; more casual
observers will have a bit more difficulty differentiating old from new.
The City Golf does have crisper edges, a bit more definition to its front
end, while the City Jetta adopts the shield front
end that is becoming a design cue for all VW products.
The interiors get spruced up, too, with the steering wheel from the new
Rabbit and new Jetta moving downscale, a new any-colour-you-like-as-long-as-it's-black
(City Golf) or -anthracite (City Jetta) upholstery, revised graphics for the
instrument
panel, and – perhaps most important for the younger demographic VW Canada
is targeting with these cars – a remarkably
sophisticated eight-speaker (six in the City Jetta) sound system, including
AM, FM, CD, MP3 player and both iPod and USB
input jacks, standard on both cars.
Fit and finish are pretty good, if maybe not quite to the standard VW established in the previous-generation cars.
The design for the 2.0 litre, single-overhead camshaft, two-valve four-cylinder
gasoline engine may have been handed down
on a second tablet to Moses.
Despite revisions over the years, this is an antique lump, paling in comparison
to the modern, multi-valve motivators in most
of the alternatives.
That said, it seemed more refined in these applications than in some other
VWs, and the 115 horsepower and 122 lb.-ft. of torque,
arriving at a very low 2600 rpm, means progress is reasonably brisk.
The biggest upgrade to the 2008s is, however, in the optional $1400 automatic
transmission: a six-speed with Tiptronic manual shift
override, unheard of at this price level.
It not only gives City Golf and City Jetta a technological advantage over
their competition, it is also perhaps the first automatic
I would recommend over a manual, especially in a small economy car.
Transport Canada fuel figures are similar for the two trannies.
The MacPherson strut front/twist-beam rear suspension has served VW well
since the 1970s and the original Rabbit.
(The current new Rabbit and Jetta finally have gone to fully-independent
rear suspension.)
But the older system in the City Golf and City Jetta continues to deliver
excellent road dynamics.
The ride is firm but well controlled.
VWs have always had good steering, and the bargain-priced City line is
no exception.
Handling is stable and entertaining.
What really separates VWs from the pack is that the cars feel larger than they really are.
The big comfortable and supportive seats, and the solid feel on the road belie the cars' compact size.
They also feel safe, because they are – safety is also built-in. Number
2 daughter has been involved in two big-time
crashes in VWs, and walked away with a total of one scratch.
Even the low-priced City Golf/Jetta have four-wheel disc brakes with ABS
as standard equipment – most cars in this
class don't offer ABS at any price.
Directional stability control, including traction control, emergency brake
assist and electronic differential lock, is a very
reasonable $450 option – again, most cars in this class don't offer this
at all.
Other critical stand-alone options include that automatic transmission
at $1,400, air conditioning at $1,350, side airbags
at $180 and side curtain bags at $450.
Various packages dial in power windows, mirrors and locks with remote (standard
on City Jetta), heated seats and washer
nozzles, all of which can easily run your "economy car" to more than 20 grand.
Then again, because many of these items are optional, you could exercise a little self-restraint.
How impressed was I with the new City Golf and Jetta?
Let's just say that Kenzie World Headquarters might well be acquiring a
new car one day soon.
The City Golf is on the short list.
2008 VW City Golf hatch/City Jetta
sedan
PRICE: Golf: $15,300. Jetta: $16.900.
ENGINE: 2.0 L four
POWER/TORQUE: 115 hp/122 lb.-ft.
FUEL ECONOMY: Manual city 9.8, hwy. 7.0; automatic city 9.9, hwy. 6.9 L/100 km
COMPETITION: Golf: Chevrolet Aveo, Honda Fit, Hyundai
Accent, Kia Rio, Nissan Versa, Pontiac Wave, Toyota Yaris.
Jetta: Chevrolet Cobalt, Ford Focus,
Honda Civic, Nissan Sentra, Pontiac G5, Toyota Corolla
WHAT'S BEST: Genuine German safety engineering; roomy; best automatic
transmission in segment; certain brand
cachet, at least in some circles
WHAT'S WORST: VW initial quality scores have not shone in recent years;
entire line is a full generation old; engine
technology is several generations old
WHAT'S INTERESTING: If you agree German engineering means something, this is the cheapest way to get it