Honda offers
an optional five-speed automatic transmission across the board. Toyota stayed
with a four-speed, reserving
a five-speed for the optional engine.
Honda penned a dramatic, futuristic look; Toyota kept mainstream, Camry-esque styling.
Honda reconfigured
the interior to match the promise of the sheet metal. Toyota's interior also
is a good match with the outside,
which means it's a bit plain.
Honda has
made power windows standard. Toyota gives you hand cranks on all but the high-end
Corolla, unless you pay
$625 for a "power package" to get electric windows (and remote door locks).
So flog Toyota round the fleet? Nope.
Turns out
Corolla, as unimaginative, uninspired and underfeatured it might seem, remains
a reassuringly solid
and appealing small car.
And add this
potentially important factor: Toyota makes stability control, including traction
control, standard on the XRS
sport model and will sell it on other models for a modest $250. It even has
an "off" switch for when the car would work
better without the traction control (in gravel or deep snow, for instance).
Honda puts stability control on the sportiest Civic but doesn't offer it on all other Civics.
The wagon-like
Matrix, based on the Corolla and also sold by Pontiac as the Vibe, was redesigned
at the same time.
It's different enough in appearance and intention that it'll be considered
on its own later.
You might
question what Toyota was smoking when it decided to keep hand-crank windows,
like those on the Corolla
Sport test car. Turns out that Toyota Motor Sales, U.S. distributor of Toyota
and Lexus vehicles, has to pay Toyota Motor Corp.,
the Japanese parent, extra for every accessory or upgrade on the U.S. models.
Making cranks standard on all but the XLE trimmed a bit from what TMS has
to pay TMC per car.
No matter
that it probably costs TMC more to stock and offer two sets of window mechanisms
than to standardize
power windows.
Honda, calling power windows "an expectation," switched 100% to power on all its vehicles in 2006.
Beyond convenience,
power windows can be a safety feature. You can lock them to prevent kids from
running them up
and down, or sticking their head and hands out when they shouldn't. And power
operation lets the driver close up quickly
when a wrong turn leads into an iffy neighborhood.
Impressions left by the test car, an $18,410 Sport with four-speed automatic and 1.8-liter engine:
•Comfortable,
reasonably roomy seating, front and rear.
The back has adequate knee room for most adults and will seat three if at
least one is skinny.
But: Not all kid seats sit squarely in back because of placement of safety-belt buckles.
•No-nonsense
dashboard.
A joy in these days of electronic madness. The materials look and feel nice
enough that you don't think "rental car."
The climate-control knobs, though, were stiff to move and rubbery in motion.
•Thoughtful
cubbies.
The trunk of the test car had a bin to keep small items from sliding about
and to separate them from grungy cargo.
Each door had a cup holder.
•Decent
dynamics.
Steering was light, but you didn't feel as if the front wheels were on ice,
or the steering wheel was disconnected.
The "feel of the road" crowd will boo, but most drivers will find it a pretty
nice setup.
The transmission,
though a four-speed, shifted crisply up or down. In fact, it provided prompt,
no-stumble downshifts
superior to some fancier boxes in pricier machines.
Still, a five-speed almost surely would improve both mileage and performance.
Brakes felt about average, which is a step up from the spongy feel common on Toyotas.
Acceleration
was acceptable, considering the meager 132 horsepower, and the four-cylinder
engine surprisingly
didn't sound strained doing its business. The pricier XRS version comes with
a 2.4-liter engine rated 158 hp.
The left
section of the folding rear seat back didn't latch securely against the bulkhead
that separates the seats from the trunk.
The latch for that section sits too far inboard, leaving the outer edge so
it could be pulled away from the bulkhead without much
effort.
Might be
a meaningless flaw — who goes around yanking the rear seat back (other than
auto writers)?
But along with the four-speed automatic and crank windows, it leaves the
impression that corners are being cut.
The shortcomings
suggest that Toyota was more focused on money than owners.
But overall, there's no quibble with the smooth, comfortable way the Corolla
goes about most of its business.
Not looking
for a song and dance from your compact car? Prefer a straightforward approach,
executed well, instead
of a platform for the latest gadgets?
Then Corolla — a pretty good, if unexciting car — could be your new friend.
ABOUT THE 2009 TOYOTA COROLLA
What is it?
Remake of
one of the world's best sellers, a four-door, front-drive compact. Toyota
says 80% are built at Fremont,
Calif., in the Toyota-run NUMMI (New United Motor Manufacturing Inc.) factory.
The rest come from Canada and Japan.
How much?
| Trim | Transmission | MSRP* | Destination** |
|---|---|---|---|
| CE | Manual 5 Speed | C$14,565 | C$1,140 |
|
|
|||
| S | Manual 5 Speed | C$18,930 | C$1,140 |
|
|
|||
| LE | Automatic 4 Speed | C$19,900 | C$1,140 |
|
|
|||
| XRS | Manual 5 Speed | C$21,655 | C$1,140 |
How many?
315,000
this year. Toyota counts the mechanically similar Matrix hatchback/wagon
as a Corolla model
and says that will add 75,000.
What's the drivetrain?
1.8-liter,
four-cylinder rated 132 horsepower at 6,000 rpm, 128 pounds-feet of torque
at 4,400 rpm, five-speed
manual transmission. Four-speed automatic is optional.
•XRS has
2.4-liter rated 158 hp at 6,000 rpm, 162 lbs.-ft. at 4,000 rpm, five-speed
manual.
The engine is not available on any of the other models. Five-speed automatic
is optional.
What's the safety gear?
Front, side
and head-curtain air bags; anti-lock brakes with brake-force distribution.
Stability control, including traction control, $250 (standard on XRS).
What's the rest?
Varies by
model, but standard on all: air conditioning, AM/FM/CD stereo with MP3, WMA
playback; power steering,
brakes, mirrors; tiltable and telescoping steering column; rear-window defroster.
More details: www.toyota.com.
How big?
178.7 inches
long, 69.3 inches wide, 57.7 inches tall, on a 102.4-inch wheelbase. Passenger
space listed as 92 cubic
feet; trunk space, 16.6 cubic feet.
•Weights range from 2,723 to 2,965 pounds, depending on equipment. Rated to tow 1,500 pounds.
•Turning circle diameter 35.6 feet (36.3 feet for XRS).
How thirsty?
1.8-liter
is rated 27 miles per gallon in town, 35 highway, 30 combined, with either
manual or automatic transmission;
2.4-liter rated 22/30/25 with either transmission. Test car's trip computer
recorded 25.1 mpg in suburban driving.
Tank holds 13.2 gallons. Regular (87-octane) gasoline specified.
Overall:
Competent underachiever.